In recent days, the bustling island paradise of Phuket has found itself at the center of a heated discussion, sparked by a controversial YouTube video. The video, uploaded on the Ride with Gabi channel, loudly labels a Myanmar migrant community in the province as a “slum,” stirring up a maelstrom of debate across digital mediums.
The video attempts to unveil what it calls a “Myanmar slum in Phuket,” capturing the everyday lives of workers hailing from Myanmar in what is depicted as a crowded and economically challenged neighborhood. These residents are said to pay around 3,600 baht monthly for rent, which generously covers utilities—a reasonable deal considering the economic landscape. Within this vibrant community, a beacon of hope stands tall in the form of a school. Guided by a spirited Myanmar national, this educational institution offers its young learners free education, meals, and even the luxury of air-conditioned classrooms—a cool respite from the tropical heat.
Sister Lakana Sukhsuchit, the dedicated director of the Good Shepherd Sisters Thailand’s center in Phuket, swiftly responded to this portrayal. She challenges the term “slum” used by the YouTuber, instead painting a picture of a humble fishing community where untidiness may just be the badge of a hardworking life tied to the unpredictable sea. “This area is not a slum as described,” she firmly states. “It is merely a community of fishermen residing by the sea, where fishing is their livelihood.”
The Good Shepherd Sisters have been a pillar of support in this community for over a decade, diligently providing educational opportunities and various forms of assistance. Occupations here are largely tied to the fishery industry, characterized by the ebbs and flows of income that mirror the ocean tides. Just last year, the school hosted 395 eager students, ranging from the tender age of five to bright-eyed adolescents of seventeen. While the majority of these students are Burmese, others belong to the Mon and Karen ethnic groups, tracing their roots back to places like Dawei, a bustling port city in Myanmar.
The school’s curriculum is as dynamic as it is inclusive, with a strong focus on teaching the Thai language to assist migrant children in acclimating to Thai schools. Burmese and English classes are also on the menu, adding an international flair to the learning experience, as reported by Bangkok Post. The video has, however, caught the attention of Thai authorities, raising security concerns and triggering official visits to the community since April 2nd. Still, Sister Lakana remains unwavering in her mission. Her charity endeavors to ensure these migrant children grow to be assets to the province, honing their potential through education and the nurturing of sound moral values.
Through the prism of education and community, the story of this vibrant Myanmar enclave in Phuket contrasts with the bleak picture painted by video creators seeking sensational narratives. Here, the emphasis is on hope, resilience, and the unyielding quest for a brighter tomorrow.
Labeling the community as a ‘slum’ is irresponsible and demeaning. It doesn’t reflect the resilience and hard work shown by the Myanmar people in Phuket!
Well, if it looks like a slum and smells like a slum, let’s be honest here, it’s probably a slum. We can’t sugarcoat reality, can we?
John, that’s a bit harsh! These people are doing the best they can under tough conditions. Would you say the same about similar communities in your own country?
I agree with Emily. We have to move past just labeling places. Context and empathy are crucial in understanding these communities.
This is why context in videos is so important. The narrative can be twisted so easily!
You’re right. But let’s not pretend a bad situation in Phuket is suddenly rosy because someone spun a ‘resilience’ narrative. The place needs help, not praise.
The issue is that many just focus on the bad without highlighting the good, which is equally important!
I think Sister Lakana’s dedication is commendable. Education is key to breaking the cycle of poverty.
Exactly! But one person or organization can’t do it all. The government should step in too.
Totally, Ben. The government needs to recognize and support these communities more.
Why is everyone so offended by the word ‘slum’? It is what it is. How else are we going to see the need for change?
Maybe it’s because words like ‘slum’ come with negative connotations that can stigmatize rather than help.
Stigma or not, isn’t acknowledging the problem the first step to fixing it?
Kudos to the Good Shepherd Sisters for doing what they can. It warms my heart to see such commitment.
Why aren’t more funds being allocated to improve these living conditions? There should be better oversight.
Mark, it’s all about priorities, unfortunately. Many governments don’t focus on these marginalized groups.
If a private individual can spark this much controversy simply by filming and labeling, we need to look at what our media is doing to actually help.
Truth is, the media often sensationalizes for clicks. But we, as consumers, are part of the problem by giving it attention.
Teaching multiple languages is such a brilliant initiative! It opens doors for these kids.
You know, with all this talk about cultural sensitivity, I really question who’s actually listening to what these communities want.
It’s great to see a positive voice amongst the noise. Sister Lakana needs more support from us all.
Thailand needs to step up its efforts. These communities contribute to the economy; they deserve better.
Maybe not labeling them as slums also helps the local morale. Words can build up or tear down.
Are there any fundraisers or ways to help Sister Lakana and the school directly?
The problem with charities is sometimes the funds aren’t managed well, but let’s hope this isn’t the case here.
There should be a greater focus on integration and not just sticking these communities away from sight.
Well said, @ethereal_mind. Inclusion is more important than ever.